Top 10 Most Expensive Homes Sold in Rutherford County in 2025

The most expensive home sold in Rutherford County in 2025 was a $10 million equestrian estate on Sharpsville Road in Murfreesboro. That sale led a strong year for luxury real estate, with the county's ten highest-priced transactions totaling nearly $35 million.

These properties ranged from sprawling farm estates in Christiana and Eagleville to custom-built homes in premier Murfreesboro subdivisions like Puckett Station and Boura. Price per square foot varied from $352 to $709, with larger acreage properties often commanding the highest premiums. When buyers can get 20, 40, or 90+ acres within 20 minutes of I-24 and downtown Murfreesboro, they pay for that scarcity.

Here is a closer look at each sale, ranked from highest to lowest price.

1. Haven Farm Equestrian Estate on Sharpsville Road — $10,000,000

4750 Sharpsville Rd, Murfreesboro, TN 37130

Haven Farm claimed the top spot by a wide margin. This 93.91-acre equestrian estate sold for $10 million in June 2025, coming in at $709 per square foot. The property includes a 14,096 square foot main residence with 5 bedrooms and 9 bathrooms, plus a 1,200 square foot guesthouse. Facilities support both equestrian and livestock operations. Located off Halls Hill Pike near TN-96, the property is zoned for Lascassas Elementary, Oakland Middle, and Oakland High School. After 238 days on market, it closed $950,000 under the original asking price.

View full property details for 4750 Sharpsville Rd

2. Riverfront Estate in Christiana on 28 Acres — $3,800,000

7005 Beverly Ct, Christiana, TN 37037

This 28.3-acre riverfront estate in the Pearson Farms area of south Rutherford County closed in July 2025. The 10,225 square foot home offers 5 bedrooms and 8 bathrooms, along with seven barns and outbuildings spread across five pastures. A private in-law apartment with elevator access adds flexibility for multi-generational living. Located off Rock Springs Midland Road, the property is zoned for Christiana Elementary, Rockvale Middle, and Rockvale High School. It sold for $150,000 under asking after 35 days on market.

View full property details for 7005 Beverly Ct

3. Contemporary Estate on Cedar Grove Road with 10+ Acres — $3,550,000

4484 Cedar Grove Rd, Murfreesboro, TN 37127

Modern design meets acreage in this 2024-built contemporary home on 10.72 acres in the Arms Farm area. The 6,347 square foot single-level residence features an H-shaped floor plan that separates private and shared spaces. A river rock courtyard, in-ground pool, and 700 square foot detached apartment complete the property. Located just off Manchester Highway near I-24 Exit 84, the home is zoned for Buchanan Elementary, Whitworth-Buchanan Middle, and Riverdale High School. It sold above asking price in August 2025 after going under contract in just 7 days.

View full property details for 4484 Cedar Grove Rd

4. New Construction in Boura Subdivision — $2,800,000

3358 Eslin Ct, Murfreesboro, TN 37130

This custom home by Chadwick General Contractors in the Boura subdivision commanded $586 per square foot, among the highest on this list. The 4,779 square foot home sits on 1.51 acres in an area with no city taxes. Located off Thompson Lane in east Murfreesboro near I-840 Exit 55, the property is zoned for Lascassas Elementary, Oakland Middle, and Oakland High School. It closed at full asking price in November 2025.

View full property details for 3358 Eslin Ct

5. Colonial Estate on 43 Acres in Eagleville — $2,780,000

1487 Highway 41A S, Eagleville, TN 37060

Historic American architecture meets 43.39 acres of Tennessee countryside in this Eagleville estate. The 6,191 square foot colonial-style home features five fireplaces, custom 8-piece crown molding, and a chef's kitchen with Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances. A barn and stable support equestrian use. Located on US-41A in southwest Rutherford County, the property is zoned for Eagleville School (K-12). After 74 days on market, it closed in September 2025.

View full property details for 1487 Highway 41A S

6. Puckett Station Luxury Home in Blackman Area — $2,500,000

1128 Julian Way, Murfreesboro, TN 37128

This Puckett Station home went under contract the same day it hit the market in January 2025. The 5,694 square foot all-brick residence sits on 1.64 acres and includes an in-ground pool and creek frontage. Located off Fortress Boulevard near I-24 Exit 76, the property is in the highly sought-after Blackman school zone (Blackman Elementary, Middle, and High School). At $439 per square foot, it represented strong value and closed in February 2025.

View full property details for 1128 Julian Way

7. Entertainer's Estate on 7 Acres in Christiana — $2,500,000

11019 Threet Rd, Christiana, TN 37037

An entertainer's dream in the Cold Saturday Farm subdivision, this 7,093 square foot home on 7.25 acres closed in January 2025. Features include three gas fireplaces, a 7-car garage, Tesla charging station, productive greenhouse, stocked pond, and developed gardens. Located off Armstrong Valley Road near Veterans Parkway (I-840 Exit 50), the property is zoned for Rockvale Elementary, Middle, and High School. It sold for $150,000 under asking after 76 days on market.

View full property details for 11019 Threet Rd

8. Eagleville Horse Farm with Mountain Views — $2,400,000

2313 Allisona Rd, Eagleville, TN 37060

This 19.76-acre horse farm in Magnolia Valley Estates moved quickly, going under contract in just 13 days. The 4,106 square foot home offers panoramic mountain views from its hilltop setting, along with a finished basement, in-ground pool, and split rail fencing. At $585 per square foot, the acreage commanded a premium. Located off Horton Highway (I-840 Exit 42) in southwest Rutherford County, the property is zoned for Eagleville School. It closed in March 2025.

View full property details for 2313 Allisona Rd

9. Creekside Estate in Puckett Station with Resort Pool — $2,380,000

1021 Julian Way, Murfreesboro, TN 37128

The second Julian Way property on this list, this 6,061 square foot home sits on 1.96 creekside acres in Puckett Station Section 8. A 16x40 saltwater pool, putting green, outdoor kitchen, and Lutron smart home system define the outdoor living experience. Geothermal heating and cooling add efficiency. Located in the Blackman school zone off Fortress Boulevard, it closed in December 2025 for $220,000 under asking after 49 days on market.

View full property details for 1021 Julian Way

10. Private 5-Acre Estate on Harrison Road — $2,200,000

1485 Harrison Rd, Murfreesboro, TN 37128

Rounding out the list is this 4,711 square foot estate on 5.1 private acres near Veterans Parkway. Built in 2023, the all-brick home features a gourmet kitchen with commercial appliances, including a butler's pantry with direct garage access. An in-ground pool, barn, and security gate complete the property. Located off Armstrong Valley Road (I-840 Exit 50), the home is zoned for Barfield Elementary, Christiana Middle, and Riverdale High School. It sold at full asking price in July 2025 after 24 days on market.

View full property details for 1485 Harrison Rd

What These Sales Tell Us About Rutherford County's Luxury Market

Three patterns stand out when you look at these ten sales together.

First, acreage commands a premium. Properties with significant land not only sold for higher total prices but often achieved higher price-per-square-foot numbers as well. When you can get 20, 40, or 90+ acres within a short drive of Murfreesboro's restaurants, shopping, and healthcare, that scarcity drives value. The $709 per square foot achieved by Haven Farm reflects what buyers will pay for that combination of space and access.

Second, pricing strategy mattered at every level. Properties that sold at or above asking price typically went under contract in less than 30 days. Homes that required 60 or more days to sell often closed below their original list price. Even buyers spending $2 million or more are paying attention to value.

Third, school zones influenced which areas attracted luxury buyers. The Blackman zone appeared twice on this list. Eagleville, with its K-12 campus, attracted buyers seeking both acreage and a tight-knit school community. Rockvale schools served several of the larger estate properties in south Rutherford County.

If you are thinking about buying or selling in the luxury market in Murfreesboro or anywhere in Rutherford County, understanding these patterns matters. The right pricing and positioning strategy can mean the difference between a quick sale at full value and months of waiting.

Frequently Asked Questions About Luxury Real Estate in Rutherford County

What was the most expensive home sold in Rutherford County in 2025?

The most expensive home sold in Rutherford County in 2025 was 4750 Sharpsville Road in Murfreesboro, known as Haven Farm. This 93.91-acre equestrian estate sold for $10,000,000 in June 2025.

How many homes sold for over $2 million in Rutherford County in 2025?

Thirteen homes sold for $2 million or more in Rutherford County in 2025. The combined sales volume for these properties was over $41 million.

What is the price per square foot for luxury homes in Murfreesboro?

In 2025, the top ten luxury sales in Rutherford County ranged from $352 to $709 per square foot. Properties with significant acreage typically achieved higher price-per-square-foot values due to land scarcity near Murfreesboro.

Which Murfreesboro neighborhoods have the most expensive homes?

Based on 2025 sales, luxury homes in Rutherford County were concentrated in Puckett Station (Blackman area), Boura subdivision (east Murfreesboro), and estate properties along Cedar Grove Road, Sharpsville Road, and in the Christiana and Eagleville areas of south and southwest Rutherford County.

How long do luxury homes take to sell in Murfreesboro?

In 2025, days on market for the top ten sales ranged from 0 to 238 days. Properties priced accurately for the market typically went under contract within 30 days. Homes requiring price adjustments often took 60 or more days to sell.

Have questions about the luxury market or want to discuss what your property might be worth? I am happy to walk through the numbers with you.